McFarlane Toys Store Reviews

Got it and yeah. Quality is really good. Feels solid. Better than I expected

I found what I needed without too much trouble, so that part was fine. The checkout took longer than I expected though, and I started feeling a little pressured with the line building up behind me. Overall it was okay, just not the smoothest visit.

I had a question and they got back to me fast. isn’t that all you really want when you need help?

I was really happy to find the exclusive figure I’d been looking for, and the whole process was easy. Checkout went smoothly without any issues, which was a relief. getting it ordered made my day—I’ve been wanting this one for a while, so I’m genuinely excited.

My order did end up arriving, but the tracking was frustrating. For days it just kept saying “pending,” so I had no real idea where the package was or when it would show up. I basically had to guess when it was coming, which wasn’t ideal.

I was kind of annoyed at first because I had to return a figure, but the actual return process was simple enough. The refund took over a week, which felt way longer than I expected. Support did reply when I reached out, just not exactly quickly. Overall, not terrible, but I definitely wish the refund part moved faster

I ordered something from McFarlane Toys Store and then pretty much immediately realized I had picked the wrong item. I messaged them to cancel it and expected it to turn into some annoying customer service thing.

But no, they got back to me fast and canceled it before it shipped, which was great. No weird runaround, no extra questions, just handled. The refund showed up not long after too. Kind of boring, but in the best way, so yeah, 5 stars from me.

The box showed up dented, which immediately made me wonder what kind of secret warehouse obstacle course it went through before getting to my door. Like, was someone testing how much damage the packaging could take? Who knows. Luckily, the figure itself was totally fine, so I’m not too mad—just mildly suspicious...

My order showed up way faster than I expected, which was a nice surprise. I definitely appreciated the quick shipping. That said, the overall experience was basic, and I wish there had been a little more communication along the way. Still, I can’t complain too much since it arrived so quickly

I might’ve just assumed shipping would show up earlier in the checkout, but it didn’t appear until late, which was a little annoying. It didn’t come across like they were trying to be sneaky or anything, just not the clearest setup. The order itself was fine once it arrived

My Spawn figure showed up in good shape, and the box was decent too, which is what I was hoping for as a collector. Shipping took a bit longer than I expected, so that was a small letdown, but overall I’m still happy with the purchase.

I was shopping around for a few McFarlane figures and this site had better prices than several other toy stores I checked. Shipping was reasonable too, which makes a big difference when you’re trying not to overpay.
From my experience, it was definitely worth it. The figures arrived in good shape, the overall cost felt fair, and I came away happy with the purchase. I’d buy from them again as long as the prices stay this reasonable.

I’ve checked mcfarlanetoysstore.com a few times when looking for figures I wanted. The site itself is easy to use, and they do have some good stuff, but the popular figures seem to sell out really fast. Restocks aren’t always clear either, so I end up checking back a lot. I’m also careful with what I spend, so it’s frustrating when something finally shows up but the total doesn’t feel worth it after shipping or when I miss a better deal elsewhere. Not a bad store overall, just wish availability was more reliable and a little more budget-friendly.

I preordered this thinking the whole process would be straightforward, but it ended up being more frustrating than I expected. Updates were slow, and I had to keep checking on things myself instead of getting clear communication. The shipping date changed too, but there wasn’t much explanation given. The item did arrive in the end, which I’m glad about, but the preorder experience definitely didn’t match what I thought I was signing up for.

I don’t know what’s going on, but my account has been kind of a mess. Sometimes I can log in just fine, and then other times it just doesn’t work for no clear reason. And the account settings keep resetting, which is really annoying because I’ll fix them and think it’s done, then suddenly they’re back to how they were before. It’s not the worst thing ever, but it’s frustrating having to keep dealing with it.

I got clear emails about my order status and shipping, so I didn’t have to guess what was going on. It was just nice to know where things stood, and the whole process felt easy enough.

I ordered a figure from outside the US, the shipping was frustrating. It took way longer than I expected, and the tracking barely updated for days... which made it hard to know what was going on. I ended up emailing twice just to get a basic answer. The figure did arrive okay in the end, but the box was a little crushed. Not the worst order I’ve ever had, but for what I paid for shipping... I expected better.

I ordered one figure and somehow got a completely different one in the box. Shipping wasn’t too bad, so I’ll give them that, but what’s the point if the order isn’t right? I had to email them and wait for a response, which was annoying. It wasn’t the worst experience ever, but is it too much to expect the item I actually ordered?

Payment worked fine for me. It went through without any issues, the confirmation came quick, and I didn’t see any extra charges or anything weird. overal, smooth.

I did manage to get one, so I guess I can’t complain too much, but the whole lottery setup felt messy. Like, really messy. It wasn’t clear what was happening half the time, and the limited drop system just feels kind of unfair. I kept checking and waiting, and it still felt random in a frustrating way. Again, I got one, but the process really could’ve been better...